VPN vs Tor: which is more private?
Also asked as: Is Tor better than a VPN? · Should I use Tor or a VPN?
Direct answer
They solve different problems. Tor routes your traffic through three relays so that no single party sees both who you are and what you do — that is anonymity, at a steep cost in speed. A VPN routes everything through one provider at near-full speed — that is privacy from your network, with trust placed in the provider. Tor when anonymity is the point; a VPN for everything else.
What Tor gives you that a VPN cannot
No single point that knows everything. The entry relay sees your address but not your destination; the exit relay sees your destination but not your address; the middle sees neither. A VPN provider, by contrast, sees both, and you are trusting its policy not to keep them. Against an adversary who could compel or compromise a provider, that difference is the whole point of Tor.
What a VPN gives you that Tor cannot
Speed and ordinariness. Tor is slow enough that video, large downloads and many ordinary sites are painful, and a large share of sites block or challenge Tor exits. A VPN runs at a fraction under your line speed, covers every app on the device, and looks to sites like a normal visitor from another country. For untrusted Wi-Fi, ISP privacy and location, it is the practical tool.
Together
Some people run Tor over a VPN so that their ISP sees a VPN rather than Tor. That is a niche need with trade-offs of its own. For most people the honest answer is the simple one: a VPN for daily privacy, Tor for the rare case where anonymity matters more than anything else.
Sources
Related questions
- Does a VPN make me anonymous?A VPN hides your address and your traffic from your network. It does not make you anonymous: accounts, cookies, fingerprinting and the provider still know.
- VPN vs proxy: what is the difference?A proxy forwards one app's traffic, often unencrypted; a VPN encrypts everything the device sends. When a proxy is enough, and where an extension sits.
- Does a VPN make internet browsing private?A VPN hides browsing from your network and ISP and hides your address from sites. It does not hide you from accounts, or from the VPN provider itself.
- What does "no-logs VPN" mean?Every VPN keeps something. "No logs" means something only when the provider names what it stores, why, for how long, and what it never touches.